Saturday, November 29, 2014

James Carlson #10: The Ethics of Elfland


G.K. Chesterton’s chapter “The Ethics of Elfland” in his book Orthodoxy addresses the subjectivity of the societally perceived objective truths in relation to the foundational truth of individual “visions” (Chesterton). Chesterton makes the revolutionary claim that “the vision is always solid and reliable. The vision is always fact” (Chesterton). At first, this statement seems impossible but after reflecting on its relevance to the power of myth I see the validity of the statement. I believe that personal perspective is, by nature, subjective but subjectivity and objectivity are matters of degrees and are two sides of the same coin. Just as cold is the absence of heat so too objectivity is the absence of objectivity. The nature of this concept harkens back to the previous discussions we have had in class regarding the ontological. What exists in reality is very much based upon the ineffable, individual experience of the person in particular. The stories we read, or rather the truths we come to experience and accept, are based upon what we subconsciously but inevitably choose.

No comments:

Post a Comment